What Should I Put in My Coffee? is the world’s first feature-length documentary about coffee creamer. Using this seemingly innocuous topic as a starting point, the film explores big ideas about farming and animal agriculture, the environment, and the role of consumers in our current food system. Lyrical passages, cheeky asides, and bold tangents take viewers on a free-associative journey through what coffee creamer means to us—personally, politically, historically, and even spiritually. It’s a film that dares to meditate on rather than simply answer one of the most looming questions of our time: is dairy ethical?